Pragmatic Goals

“This”:http://www.touchstonemag.com/archives/article.php?id=20-07-015-v came to my inbox by way of “these people”:http://zoaearts.com. Money quote:

In Catholic worship with its sacramental focus, O’Connor found her sense of mystery nourished, and saw such nourishment as a key to the writer’s ability to “penetrate concrete reality”: “The more sacramental his theology, the more encouragement he will get from it to do just that.”

Does their theology of the sacraments preclude Evangelicals from nurturing their writers in this way? Not necessarily. Metaphor and symbolism are central to the creative process for writers, and they are an important way in which we evoke and assimilate mystery.

One need not believe in transubstantiation to make the Lord’s Supper more central in worship, nor does a symbolic or metaphorical view of the sacrament render it irrelevant to the lives of artists. But Evangelicals have too quickly and too often reacted to what they perceive as the abuses of the biblical sacrament in the Mass by relegating the Eucharist to a marginal role in their worship.

This cannot be unrelated to the fact that we as a community can seem too much like the generation O’Connor described, “that has been made to feel that the aim of learning is to eliminate mystery.” Our services, like our fiction, are justified by their efficiency in achieving pragmatic goals. Our sermons are full of practical, easy steps to spiritual victory, a better marriage, or financial success; our music is designed to express comfortable emotions; everything is aimed at maximizing the body count at the altar call.

Some of these goals are worth pursuing, but perhaps if abasement before a transcendent deity, felt as such, were one of them, we would produce better Christians and better writers.

2 Comments

  1. Posted September 14, 2007 at 8:49 am | Permalink

    I enjoyed the whole article, and want to spend some time thinking about it more.

    Now, if I can just find that time to spend…

  2. Posted September 18, 2007 at 10:59 am | Permalink

    Um… that seems so interesting, but do you have like… a version in simple English that maybe people who don’t read books that much can understand?

    I seriously finished reading that and thought “What did I just read?”…

    Big words that made this impossible to get…

    *sacramental
    *theology
    *Evangelicals
    *Metaphor (ok, I know this one)
    *assimilate (I learned this one because of the Borg)
    *transubstantiation (SLOW DOWN PROFESSOR!)
    *sacrament
    *relegating
    *Eucharist
    *pragmatic
    *abasement (OK, HANGING UP NOW. I’M TOO STUPID TO TALK TO YOU)
    *transcendent
    *deity (BYE!)

    Dude… there’s no Google Translate button for Christianese!!!